
Hazem Kassem
Reviewed by Hazem Kassem — Founder & Managing Director, CMA, ACCA Certificate in IFRS Read bio →
12 min read
A textile manufacturer serving big brands believed his company made about 25% net profit. It made 12%. A well-established software company had reported healthy profits for years. Its real profit was about 10% of the reported figure. Neither owner was careless. Both were reading numbers that looked right and answered the wrong question.
After 25+ years as a CFO, I've learned that profit rarely disappears in one dramatic place. It leaks in a few predictable ones. This study walks through six of them, with two real cases from our work (names removed) and illustrative examples you can redo with your own figures. At the end there is a six-question self-check you can run this week.
1. Reading gross margin as if it were net profit
The textile owner priced his products from the buying and selling prices. The gap was about 50%, so he assumed that after "some expenses" he kept roughly half of it: 25% net. Once every cost was captured and allocated to the right place, the real net margin was 12%.
Illustrative example (same pattern, rounded figures): revenue 40 million, gross margin 50% = gross profit 20 million. Then administration 6 million, selling and distribution 4 million, finance costs 2.2 million and depreciation 3 million, a total of 15.2 million. Net profit before tax: 20 − 15.2 = 4.8 million, which is 12% of revenue, not 25%.
That clarity drove three fixes in the real case: prices were renegotiated where the market had room, large waste in inventory and production cycles was removed, and a proper system started capturing every transaction on time. Net margin rose gradually to about 20–22%.
Check: is your net margin calculated from full costs every month, or estimated from your gross margin?
2. Revenue recorded before it is earned, costs recorded away from their revenue
In the software company, revenue was recognised before its time and costs were not matched to the revenue they produced. The result: real profit was about 10% of what the reports showed, and the company had been paying tax on profit it never made. The lower, true number became a wake-up call; management refocused on winning new business, a financial controller and a proper system made the monthly numbers reliable, and real profit doubled the following year and tripled by the third.
Illustrative example: reported profit 10 million. Inside it, a three-year contract billed upfront for 12 million was recorded in full this year, although only 4 million belongs to this year: profit is overstated by 8 million. Another 1 million of project costs that belong to this year sit on the balance sheet as "work in progress". Real profit: 10 − 8 − 1 = 1 million, or 10% of the reported figure.
Check: for your three biggest contracts, can your accountant show how much revenue and cost belongs to this year, and why?
Continue reading: 4 more places profit hides, the self-check and next steps
Enter your email to read the rest now. You'll also receive From the CFO's Desk, one practical finance letter a month from Hazem Kassem. Unsubscribe any time.
